Check your review replies · Guide Series

Influence the narrative in your favor — fill the silence

Your Reply Rate, how many customers who spoke up heard back, is one of the four practice measures at the heart of The Reciprocity Method™.

Start here

Most owners know their star rating. Few are ever shown how long their customers wait for an answer. A customer who writes a review has spoken first, in public, and then they wait. In a study of 46,771 recent Google reviews of 986 local service businesses, 58.9% got an owner reply, 12.0% got one within a week, and the typical reply took 27 days. Here is a way to look at your own.

From The Reciprocity Method™ · about a 4-minute read · November 2026

Run the check in three steps

The check at a glance
  1. Your newest 20 reviewsCopied from your profile
  2. The promptPasted into an AI chat
  3. The tableChecked before you read on
  1. Copy your reviews

    Open your Google Business Profile and sort your reviews by Newest, then copy the most recent 20, each with its date, its star rating, and your reply if you replied. Leave out reviewers’ names and any employee names.

  2. Paste the prompt

    Open any AI chat assistant, paste the prompt below, then paste your reviews under it.

  3. Check the table first

    Check the table it shows you first, then read the rest.

No AI handy?

Look at your last 10 reviews and count how many have a reply from you. That count is your starting point.

The prompt to copy

Copy all of it, exactly as written. The rules at the end keep the answer on your own practice.

The reply checkPaste into any AI chat assistant, then paste your reviews under itPrompt

I want to check one habit in my business: how I answer the public reviews my customers leave. Below this message I will paste my most recent Google reviews. Each has its date, its star rating, and my reply if I replied.

Work only from what I paste. If something is missing or unclear, ask me; do not guess. If I paste fewer than 10 reviews, tell me the sample is too small to judge and stop.

First show me a table, one row per review: its date as written, its stars, whether I replied, and its group. The groups are: 1 or 2 stars is "unhappy", 4 or 5 stars is "happy", 3 stars is "middle". Under the table, show the totals: reviews, replies, and reviews and replies in each group. Stop there and let me check the table and the totals before you say anything else.

Once I confirm, use only those totals and tell me in plain words:

1. My reply rate: how many of these reviews I answered, as a count and a percentage.

2. Who is still waiting: every review with no reply, oldest first, with its date and star rating.

3. Whether I answer unhappy customers as often as happy ones, side by side, leaving the middle group out. If either group has fewer than 5 reviews, say it is too few to compare. Report only; do not tell me which group to answer first.

4. The one place to look first, and one small step I can take this week.

Rules for your answer. Measure my practice only. Do not estimate how fast I reply; the dates are too rough for that. Do not write or suggest ways to ask customers for reviews. Do not suggest asking any customer to change, update or remove a review, or offering anything in return for a review. Do not suggest treating customers differently by star rating. Do not set a star-rating goal or a review-count goal. Do not predict that replying will bring more or better reviews. Do not repeat any reviewer's name, any employee's name or my business's name. Do not draft replies unless I ask afterwards.

What you get back

Here is the shape of the answer, drawn from a made-up sample.

Sample result: 20 reviews, one mark each
A sample with made-up numbers, from no real business. Yours will differ.
Sample result: who got an answer
The same made-up sample. The prompt reports the two side by side and leaves the reading to you.

Check the count first

An AI assistant can miscount. That is why the prompt makes it show its table and its totals before anything else. Check them against your own reviews. If a row or a total is wrong, tell it which one, and have it correct the table before you read on.

How your numbers compare

From the study
58.9%of reviews got an owner reply
12.0%got one within a week
27 daysthe typical wait for a reply

In the same study, 58.9% of reviews got an owner reply, 12.0% got one within a week, and the typical reply took 27 days. The sample: claimed listings with 30 or more reviews, five trades, ten large US metros, each business’s newest 50 reviews. Your figures come from 20 reviews and approximate dates, so read the study as a reference point, not a grade. Full study and method.

Run this again next month and see what moved.

Where replying sits in the four measures
  • Ask CoverageWho was invited to share how it went
  • Moment FidelityWhen they were invited, and in what words
  • Reply RateThis check: the reviews you answered
  • Resolution RateThe problems you closed
The four practice measures of The Reciprocity Method™. All four count what the team did, never what customers wrote.

Replying is one of four habits.

Replying is one of four everyday habits behind how customers experience a business. To see where your team stands on all four, take the free two-minute Reputation Diagnostic.